Sunday, November 15, 2026

Domhnall Gleeson in INCOMER Drew Me In then Left me Out to Sea-DON'T SEE

The independent film "The Incomer" airing on Fandango is an incredulous comedy intended to be charming and disarming. Sadly, the idyllic rustic setting and stirring performances of its two earnest leads, Domhnall Gleeson as Daniel, as an abject civil servant who serves eviction notices and Gayle Rankin as Isla an island inhabitant about to be served. The fierce but naive island native Isla, along with her brother Sandy (Grant O'Rourke) have somehow managed to survive as the sole inhabitants of this majestic cliffside island off the coast of Scotland. There are plenty of scenes here to admire including the ongoing dialogue between Isla and a demonic seacreature, evening fireside chats between the brother and sister, the mundane sustenance the siblings ensue to ensure survival and the outlandish but endearing rituals the two pursue for entertainment and overall sanity. The casting of Domnhall Gleeson star of Peacock series "The Paper" and leading film actor ("Ex Machina" and "Unbroken") He is also the son of acclaimed Irish actor Gleeson. Daniel is a nerdy office worker dubbed an "incomer" by Sandy and Isla. Daniel becomes endeared by the innocent and bizarre behaviors of Isla and Sandy. However, it was too strenuous a stretch to make the premise of the two (30 somethings?) having survived by themselves for 30 odd years with no outside contact or assistance. (Perhaps, the time span could've been reduced for credibilities sake.) But, the siblings are convincing as the squabbling, feral familial islanders who are won over by Daniel with his tenacity, kindness and story telling that endears him to both Isla and Sandy. Daniel dons the outlandish costumes and customs orchestrated by them and becomes attached to this unorthodox pair. Daniel consents to allow them to decide for themselves whether to remain on the island in the only home they've known or be transplanted in a home provided on the mainland.  An awkward romantic moment between Daniel and Isla scores a hit. But there are too many misfires as with the felonious office misfit whom the villainous boss assigns to "do whatever needs to be done to vacate the island." Sandy and Isla are somewhat successful and comical in thwarting the invasive "incomers" who intend to remove them.  But,  there are more off-putting scenes as when Sandy attempted to strangle Daniel in his plan to "eat you {Daneil} and have you with me at all times," These objectionable scenes mitigate for what might have been a tender, humorous and enchanting film.  I wanted to squawk praise for what I hoped would be a touching and quirky film. But there are too many mistakes that shriek louder than a flock of seagulls squabbling amongst the waves. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Don't be shy, let me know what you think