I didn't fancy SF Ballet's "Mere Mortals" (2024) choreographed by Aszure Barton with music by Floating Points. Here's several reasons why. First and foremost, there was too little dancing, too much monotonous prancing, posing and video showings. For those who love the ballet (as do I ) a modicum of ballet is a prerequisite. This ballet contained only a slight amount of ballet dancing. Ballet in "Mere Mortals" was missing in action. The concept of AI as a genesis for a creative work could work nicely. With the omnipresent invasion of AI, incorporating it into the ballet repertoire was Absolutely Intriguing; especially around the Bay Area. Carmen Kovacs, the dramaturgist* for the piece said blending the Greek Myth Pandora and AI, "The audience doesn't have to know the myth at all to take meaning from the ballet because you will naturally feel what it's about..." I came to the ballet not knowing the Pandora Myth was part of the pastiche. I was aware of the AI Aspect Intended. And, I expected some relevant storytelling or arguments for or against its usage. The ballet failed to deliver much to ponder but much to wonder. How the finished product got approved for presentation due to its lackluster choreography and waste of energy. The use of video can add to production value. The ballet began with a video of what looked like the inside of a volcano which spewed its lava flow. A tall dancer in cossack style dress entered. He was foreboding and overbearing of the dancers. The corps ballet attired in form-fitting black leotards appeared as a populous that functioned as a whole without variation (as in the TV series "Pluribus"**). Choreographer Barton borrowed from his earlier, far superior work, "Busk" (2019). "Busk" was more creative, cunning and exciting. The facial expressions (or lack thereof) in "Busk" served to portray street entertainers; hence its title. Azsure also used frenetic running on stage which was a poor imitation of Balanchine's "Glass Pieces". Perhaps, "Mere Mortals" work would work better as a short piece rather than a full ballet. The couple in their body-fitting latex with metallic coloration stood out nicely from the ensemble in their pas des deus. The uniformity of the masses contrasted with the separate, free-thinking, duo dancers. This gave pause to consider dangers of too much reliance on AI. I do have high praise for the soloists whose movements mirrored balloons rippling out front of used car lots. A flagrant waste of time was spent with a dancer, back turned to the audience, standing stock-still on-stage merely watching a video for five monotonous minutes. I commend the originality of the score by Floating Points, a.k.a. Sam Shepherd. The soloists captured the musicality of the electronic sounding score that was neither discordant, nor melodic, but definitely hypnotic. (It put the two seniors next to me to sleep for the entire performance.) Merde! I paid $245 for my seat. I saw "Mere Mortals" on Sunday for the first and only time. I will not be back for an encore.
*A dramaturgist aids the development of a work by providing literary or historical context and supports the creative team in telling the intended story.
**"Pluribus